From the one extreme, he put ‘generalized reciprocity’ because a powerful manifestation of solidarity. These are purchases motivated from the altruism, usually irreversible and also named ‘hospitality’, ‘help’ or ‘generosity’. Sahlins’ next sort of was ‘healthy reciprocity’ recognized as a primary change that’s always quicker personal and a lot more financial, with some form of harmony anywhere between contractors. At the opposite end of one’s spectrum was ‘bad reciprocity’, and this requires making an application for things to possess little without implications (Sahlins 2017 , 174–78). In the code out-of economics, it requires maximising earnings and you can minimising will cost you. In the extreme situations, the new transfer regarding stuff off A to B – from just one individual, class or neighborhood to another – is with zero restrict-import. Sahlins’ exemplary circumstances are a lot of means between negotiate so you can haggling, gaming and you can theft. Contained in this method, looting was a sign of ‘negative reciprocity’ – a kind of exchange that’s non-societal, unpassioned and mostly based towards the money.
What this means is a picture of social fairness according to balance and you can proportion, in which the dating should be discussed and understood since kinds of change (Graeber 2012 , 128)
The exact opposite posts of the design was laid out into the ethical conditions since the negative and positive reciprocity. So it financial code hidden the way we develop judgments throughout the our common debt throws looting from the hub away from discussions in the article-battle morality. Looting is actually an operate you to entirely inhibits social affairs: somebody requires some thing as opposed to giving anything reciprocally. The necessity of morality often is underscored for the over the top moments out-of human susceptability, whenever looting gets widespread of course, if the high quality control and you can defense of things end up being unlikely. Therefore, since Stuart Environmentally friendly cards, looting can often be evaluated so much more harshly than just mere theft otherwise theft and you will appears to are entitled to more serious discipline (Green 2007 ).
The situational character of looting, however, need further differentiation, given that phenomenon’s analysis try radically some other from inside the cases of absolute disaster or societal unrest (Mac Ginty 2004 ). Russell R. Dynes and Enrico L. Quarantelli features debated that what connects these situations try a temporary re-comparison of your public understanding of possessions (Dynes and Quarantelli 1968 ), however, that redefinition doesn’t constantly speak to larger personal assistance. In the case of disasters, you will find a social opinion based on that the condition regarding individual home is briefly frozen. This means that, items begin to function as well-known goods – they get to be the possessions of your own neighborhood. This might be a form of relationship one David Graeber named ‘communism’ – a particular second out of reciprocity, where natural readiness to cooperate and you can share when you look at the a time of drama is actually extensively practised ( 2012 , 96). In the example of looting throughout the public unrest, possessions rights are indeed redefined, however, so it happens in an atmosphere from dispute. There’s absolutely no universal contract from the seizing otherwise ‘sharing’ objects into the an emergency, but really this does not mean that there is also no societal allowed or comprehension of for example acts. Looting in cases like this was for this reason a sign of discontinuity in the fresh public consensus on what you certainly can do by just who into the available topic resources. It has been characterised from the a whole diminished intent to help you present social interactions ranging from anyone.
This sort of reciprocity assumes on several corners away from a relationship for the which wants to rating as much as possible having him/by herself
The anthropological thought of exchange may benefit the latest interpretation from the trend, and this inside a large part of Gloss area but is however under-explored. Inside historic context, the practice of looting is founded on the fresh remarkable breakup regarding subjects off objects (Germans from their assets) so you’re able to expose a separate reference to procedure things. Looting involves the definitive revocation out of good (former) user’s property legal rights. Post-conflict levels detailing the new seizure off material stuff left throughout the so-called Recovered Areas because of the expelled Germans show just how (former) customers was in fact as well as denied assets rights on an ethical level.
Deixe uma resposta